Sourdough Forge vs Sourdough Starter Tracker (2026):
Which App Is Better?
If you're looking for the best sourdough starter tracking app, you may have come across both Sourdough Starter Tracker and Sourdough Forge. This guide breaks down the key differences.
🏆 Quick Verdict
Sourdough Forge is the better choice if you want more than just starter reminders — including bake tracking, recipe workflows, full journaling, and AI troubleshooting support.
Sourdough Starter Tracker is best for bakers who only want a lightweight starter feeding tracker without additional baking features.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Sourdough Forge | Sourdough Starter Tracker |
|---|---|---|
| Starter feeding reminders | ||
| Starter health tracking | Advanced | Basic |
| Multiple starters supported | Yes (Pro) | Limited |
| Bake scheduling & timelines | ||
| AI Sourdough Coach | ||
| Recipe saving & repeatable bakes | ||
| Bake journal with photos | ||
| Best for beginners | Coaching + guidance | Simple tracking only |
| Price (Monthly) | $5.99 | Varies |
| Price (Lifetime) | $14.99 | Varies |
Utility vs. Complete System
Starter Tracker: Simple Utility
Sourdough Starter Tracker is mainly designed to remind you when to feed and log basic activity. It’s perfect if your only goal is "Don’t forget to feed my starter."
Forge: The Complete Journey
Sourdough Forge goes far beyond starter reminders. It supports the full process: readiness tracking, bake scheduling, recipe management, and AI coaching. The goal is: Track everything. Learn from every loaf.
AI Coaching: A Major Advantage
One of the biggest differences is support when something goes wrong. Sourdough Forge includes a built-in AI Sourdough Coach.
Forge gives instant answers for:
- Weak fermentation
- Dense crumb issues
- Overproofing signs
- Starter health checks
Sourdough Starter Tracker does not include AI guidance.
Who Should Choose Which?
Choose Sourdough Forge if:
- You want a complete sourdough system
- You want starter + bake tracking together
- You want AI help when something goes wrong
- You want journaling + repeatable improvement
Choose Starter Tracker if:
- You only want a lightweight feeding reminder app
- You want simple starter-only tracking
- You want minimal setup and features
Value for Money
Monthly
$5.99
Lifetime
$14.99
Best Value
Get the exact same starter tracking features plus a complete baking system for one low price.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Sourdough Forge better than Sourdough Starter Tracker?
Sourdough Forge is better for bakers who want an all-in-one sourdough system with starter health tracking, bake journaling, recipes, scheduling, and AI coaching. Sourdough Starter Tracker is mostly a basic feeding reminder app.
Does Sourdough Starter Tracker include bake scheduling?
No. It focuses mainly on starter feedings and does not provide full bake planning tools.
Which app is best for long-term sourdough improvement?
Sourdough Forge is designed for long-term improvement through journaling, repeatable workflows, and AI troubleshooting support.
Can I track full recipes and bakes with Sourdough Forge?
Yes. Forge supports recipes, full bake logs, photos, and repeatable bake workflows.
Track smarter, bake better.
Upgrade from a simple tracker to a complete sourdough companion.
Try Sourdough Forge FreeAvailable on iOS • Free trial included